Plans to convert the Crookes Valley Methodist Church into student cluster flats were approved on Tuesday by Sheffield Council.
Last week we reported that the controversial plans had split the community. You can read the full story here.
Local residents strongly opposed the approval of the plans calling the flats ‘rabbit hutches’. The conversion will involve dividing the church into five floors with a total of 19 cluster flats. In total the building will house 98 students.
Leading the objections was a Crookesmoor resident and architect Ann Daw. She said “The density of development will result in low ceilings, crowded kitchens and little daylight. There are too many floors. Some rooms will not have a window.”
The Harcourt Community Action Group were worried about the future of the building. Their spokesman Stuart Astill explained “The plan is to sell the 98 bedrooms to different owners – which will make it very difficult to protect the building in future.”
The Labour majority planning committee voted through the development that will protect the Grade II listed exterior of the building. However, the three Lib Dems on the council opposed the scheme citing the council’s CS41 planning regulations that only 20% of the area’s housing should be HMOs. Currently the figure stands at 47%.
Lib Dem councillor Paul Scriven said “This plan is the equivalent of rabbit hutching human beings.”
A consultant for the developer; Northern Eye Properties said “These will be bespoke properties for overseas and mature students with hotel-standard accommodation which complies with guidelines.”












